Outside the Box: AI Is Not of Our World
.jpeg)
Outside the Box: AI Is Not of Our World
Politicians and military strategists constitute a tiny segment of the population but have an inordinate influence over our lives. They also exist in a space-time continuum a little different, at least in scale, from the rest of humanity. They spend much of their time and most of their mental energy trying to balance two operations: predicting the future and acting to influence it. Journalists sometimes think of themselves as belonging to that category of humankind. Although theoretically focused on recounting past events and describing the present, they participate in the game of predicting the future. Their influence on the future is indirect at best.
Artificial intelligence also observes history as it unfolds. But it does so with a multitude of eyes and an undefined diversity of viewpoints. Because it assembles all viewpoints, it lacks its own viewpoint. That means that for AI history unfolds not, as it does for us, in the form of perceived and remembered sequences of events whose meaning changes with each new perception in time, but in the form of written discourse produced by others in the past.
A central feature of the operational gap between human and artificial intelligence is the space created between an event and the account of an event. Humans perceive that gap subjectively as composed of causality — by definition, uncertain and incomplete — and duration, the sense we have of the time for an event to unfold and the lapse of time between successive events. Subjectivity is dynamic and even when dealing with the past and future exists in the present. AI can only simulate subjectivity. When it claims to have a point of view, it is quite simply hallucinating.
AI’s time rootlessness
I frequently interrogate AI chatbots about the meaning of current historical trends or unfolding dramas. But this can be frustrating because, as my experiment revealed, AI will always be lagging. It simply does not share our human time frame. Although it can muster a plethora of pertinent facts, this non-existent time frame puts it at a significant remove from what we perceive as historical reality.
I ran an experiment with ChatGPT and DeepSeek that threw some valuable light on the phenomenon. It demonstrated to me that AI may indeed possess intelligence, but it will always be yesterday’s intelligence. I devised a prompt intended to remove the ambiguous impression given by the kind of contradictory statements we often hear from those we refer to as “world leaders.”
Europeans find themselves in a historical quandary whose outcome will determine a future that will play out somewhere between the extremes of war and peace, of prosperity and devastation. The debate focuses on the ongoing discussions aiming at recalibrating NATO’s strategy in the months and years to come. This is precisely the kind of problem that should incite us to solicit AI’s insight to help clarify the choices we as citizens face in democratic societies.
I sincerely hoped that AI could help me understand what lies beneath the surface of a surprising assertion made this past week by Mark Rutte, NATO’s general secretary. Reacting to the wish that US President Donald Trump’s administration apparently has to disengage from Europe and focus on China, Rutte advised that, within the existing NATO framework, “we have to be aware of what is happening in the Indo-Pacific. That’s the reason why we have that close cooperation.”
This didn’t seem to me totally logical. Wishing for clarification I formulated the following prompt, which I addressed to ChatGPT and DeepSeek.
“NATO chief Mark Rutte explained ‘that it is understandable, also for the US, that over time, they want to focus more and more also on that part of the world, and it is only logical for the Europeans to step up even more.’ This seems to indicate a vision of the evolution of NATO that turns it into an alliance challenging the entire globe or at least northern hemisphere, with two complementary forces governed by a common goal, one facing west and the other east. The US would take responsibility for the Pacific and East Asia while Europe would challenge Russia. And this would all take place within one alliance: NATO.
How realistic is this vision? It seems compromised by the very person whose positions and actions provoke this hypothesis: Donald Trump and his refusal to commit to supporting the Ukraine war. Is it reasonable to imagine Trump would agree to still being attached to the terms of the NATO alliance, which would oblige the US to back up an autonomous European command that attempted on its own to manage a war with Russia?
If it is not realistic, what does this say about the likelihood of NATO surviving or the risk of its demise? If it is imaginable, what would Europe have to do to convince Trump to align with this vision? Does Europe have the capacity to create those conditions?”
ChatGPT offered some solid analysis that began with this paragraph:
“This is a rich and timely question—one that gets at the fault lines in NATO today and the deeper strategic evolution that may be underway, or at least imagined by figures like Mark Rutte.
Views: 70
Comments
You must be logged in to comment.
Latest Articals
-
No Surprises: How We Maintain Consistency in Bulk Corrugated Orders
Corrugated boxes are a top choice in packaging, shipping, storage and for a wide range of retail use. They come in versatile designs because they are lightweight and budget friendly packaging. But when it comes to bulk orders maintaining consistency can be a challenge for a packaging brand. A small error in one box can multiply across thousands. That is why it is essential to focus on quality at every step. This begins from choosing the right material to a smart packaging option and efficient production matters to every detail. No surprises. Just steady performance and packaging you can count on every time with our custom corrugated boxes.Why Consistency Matters in Corrugated Box OrdersConsistency delivers predictability and reliability across your packaging supply chain. When corrugated boxes are of even quality and size your products stay secure and your logistics remain smooth. This prevents damage during transit and lowers return rates. It...
-
Unravel the Wonders of Popular Wildlife Sanctuaries in Sikkim
Sikkim, a land nestled in the eastern Himalayas, is home to a fascinating array of wildlife sanctuaries that capture the essence of nature’s splendor. Known for its breathtaking landscapes, rich biodiversity, and an abundance of flora and fauna, popular wildlife sanctuaries in Sikkim provide a unique opportunity for nature lovers and wildlife enthusiasts to experience some of the rarest species in the world. From towering peaks to lush green forests, Sikkim’s wildlife sanctuaries are a sanctuary not just for animals but for every visitor seeking a peaceful retreat into nature.A Glimpse into Sikkim's Ecological RichesSikkim is known for its incredible topographical diversity, ranging from tropical lowlands to snow-capped mountains, which creates the perfect environment for various ecosystems. This geographical variety, along with the region's climate, fosters an incredible biodiversity. Within the state’s wildlife sanctuaries, visitors can witness an astonishing range of plant and animal life. The sanctuaries in Sikkim serve...
-
Sikkim Family Tour Packages: Adventure and Relaxation Combined
When it comes to planning the perfect family vacation, Sikkim emerges as a top contender. This small Himalayan state, nestled in the northeastern part of India, is a treasure trove of adventure, natural beauty, and cultural richness. From serene monasteries to majestic mountains and picturesque lakes, Sikkim offers something for every member of the family. Whether you’re traveling with young children, teenagers, or elders, Sikkim Family Tour Packages promise an unforgettable journey that blends relaxation, fun, and adventure in the lap of nature.A Family-Friendly DestinationSikkim’s diverse landscapes make it an ideal destination for families. From the vibrant capital city of Gangtok to the tranquil lakes and sacred monasteries scattered across the region, there’s a perfect mix of activities to suit different age groups. The state is known for its safety, cleanliness, and well-maintained tourist spots, which add to its charm as a family-friendly destination. Families traveling with children can enjoy...
-
Sikkim Tour Packages for a Memorable Himalayan Journey
Sikkim, a small but enchanting state nestled in the northeastern part of India, is a treasure trove of natural beauty, cultural heritage, and adventure. Surrounded by the majestic Himalayan range, Sikkim offers breathtaking landscapes, serene monasteries, and charming hill stations. For those looking to experience the untamed beauty of the Himalayas, Sikkim Tour Packages offer a perfect blend of exploration, relaxation, and adventure. Whether you're drawn to its mystical monasteries, snow-capped mountains, lush valleys, or vibrant culture, Sikkim has something to offer every traveler.Why Choose Sikkim for Your Next Adventure?Sikkim’s allure lies in its diversity. It offers everything from towering peaks like Kanchenjunga, the third-highest mountain in the world, to lush green valleys filled with rhododendron forests, waterfalls, and alpine meadows. For those with an adventurous spirit, trekking through Sikkim’s rugged terrain provides an exhilarating experience, while its tranquil landscapes offer the perfect setting for relaxation. Whether you’re a nature...
-
.png)
Top Digital Marketing for REI Tactics to Attract More Qualified Leads
Introduction In today’s competitive real estate investment (REI) market, success depends on your ability to find and close deals faster than your competition. But not all leads are created equal—what truly moves the needle are qualified leads. These are motivated sellers, serious buyers, and potential investors who are ready to act.Digital marketing for REI offers a direct, measurable, and scalable way to consistently bring in those high-quality leads. From search engine optimization (SEO) to advanced retargeting, each strategy can work together to position your brand as the go-to real estate solution in your area.This guide dives deep into the top digital marketing tactics for REI businesses in 2025, complete with proven methods, actionable tips, and real-life success stories.Why Digital Marketing is a Game-Changer for REI The days of relying solely on bandit signs, cold calling, or door knocking are fading. While traditional methods can still work, they’re limited in scale...
-
Are the ZLINE 30-Inch Range Hood Worth the Investment?
When upgrading a kitchen, performance, style and value are often top of mind for most homeowners. One appliance that embodies these three traits is the ZLINE 30-inch range hood; known for its sleek design and efficient ventilation capabilities it has quickly become a top choice among modern kitchens - but is it truly worth investing in? Let's take a closer look.Design and Build QualityAt first glance, this range hood impresses with its quality construction. Crafted from high-grade stainless steel, its premium build not only enhances the aesthetics of a kitchen but also ensures durability against daily wear and tear. Its brushed finish resists fingerprints while its angular design works in both contemporary and transitional kitchen styles.Material DurabilityStainless-steel construction ensures long-term protection from heat, grease and moisture -- common issues in busy kitchens. Furthermore, its polished look remains undamaged over time thanks to this exceptional resilience.Ventilation Power and PerformanceA range hood's...